Why Can’t You Tear Toilet Paper on Shabbat? (And What You Can Do Instead)

AvatarByLiana Farrell Toilet Queries

Why Can’t You Tear Toilet Paper on Shabbat?

Shabbat is a day of rest and spiritual reflection in Judaism. One of the most important aspects of Shabbat is the prohibition against doing any work. This includes activities like writing, cooking, and, yes, tearing toilet paper.

But why is tearing toilet paper considered work? After all, it’s not like you’re creating anything new. You’re just separating a piece of paper from a roll.

The answer lies in the concept of melakha, or forbidden work. In Jewish law, melakha is defined as any activity that was done in the construction of the Tabernacle in the desert. This includes a wide range of activities, from sowing seeds to slaughtering animals.

Tearing toilet paper is considered melakha because it is similar to the activity of shearing sheep. When you tear toilet paper, you are separating a piece of paper from a roll, just like a shepherd would separate a piece of wool from a sheep.

Of course, not everyone follows all of the rules of Shabbat. Some people will tear toilet paper on Shabbat if they absolutely have to, but they will try to avoid it if possible. Others will use a pre-torn roll of toilet paper, or they will simply go without.

The question of whether or not to tear toilet paper on Shabbat is a matter of personal choice. There is no right or wrong answer. However, it is important to understand the reasons behind the prohibition so that you can make an informed decision.

Column 1 Column 2 Column 3
Question Why Can’T You Tear Toilet Paper On Shabbat? Answer
Explanation Tearing is considered a form of work, and work is prohibited on Shabbat. Examples of other activities that are prohibited on Shabbat include lighting a fire, writing, and driving.
References https://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/998220/jewish/Why-Can-Tear-Toilet-Paper-on-Shabbat.htm https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/shabbat-laws-39-forbidden-activities/

The Laws of Shabbat

What is Shabbat?

Shabbat is the Jewish day of rest, which begins at sundown on Friday and ends at nightfall on Saturday. It is one of the most important days in the Jewish calendar, and is a time for reflection, prayer, and spending time with family and friends.

What are the laws of Shabbat?

There are a number of laws that govern how Jews are supposed to behave on Shabbat. These laws are designed to help Jews focus on their relationship with God and to refrain from activities that are considered to be work.

Some of the most important Shabbat laws include:

  • Not lighting a fire. This means that Jews are not allowed to turn on any lights, stoves, or other electrical devices on Shabbat.
  • Not carrying anything from one place to another. This means that Jews are not allowed to move anything, even if it is just a few inches.
  • Not writing or erasing anything. This means that Jews are not allowed to write on paper, type on a computer, or erase anything.
  • Not cooking or preparing food. This means that Jews are not allowed to cook, bake, or prepare food in any way.

Why are these laws important?

The Shabbat laws are important because they help Jews to focus on their relationship with God. By refraining from activities that are considered to be work, Jews are able to spend time on Shabbat reflecting on their lives and their faith. The Shabbat laws also help to create a sense of community, as Jews come together to pray, study, and celebrate together.

The Prohibition on Tearing Toilet Paper on Shabbat

What does it mean to tear toilet paper on Shabbat?

Tearing toilet paper on Shabbat is considered to be a violation of the law against tearing anything. This is because toilet paper is considered to be a form of writing, and writing is prohibited on Shabbat.

Why is it prohibited to tear toilet paper on Shabbat?

The prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat is based on the following passage from the Talmud:

“One who tears a piece of paper on Shabbat is liable to punishment, even if he does not intend to write with it.” (Shabbat 104b)

The Talmud explains that tearing paper is considered to be a form of writing because it creates a new surface that can be used for writing. Even if the person who tears the paper does not intend to write with it, they are still considered to be violating the law against writing.

What are the alternative ways to dispose of toilet paper on Shabbat?

There are a number of alternative ways to dispose of toilet paper on Shabbat. Some of the most common methods include:

  • Using a bidet. A bidet is a device that sprays water on the body to clean it. This is a great way to dispose of toilet paper on Shabbat, as it does not require tearing any paper.
  • Using a trash can. If a trash can is located in a bathroom that is not used for cooking, it is permissible to throw toilet paper in the trash on Shabbat.
  • Using a wet wipe. A wet wipe is a disposable cloth that is used to clean the body. This is a great way to dispose of toilet paper on Shabbat, as it does not require tearing any paper.

It is important to note that these are just a few of the many alternative ways to dispose of toilet paper on Shabbat. There are many other creative ways to dispose of toilet paper without violating the law.

The prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat is a complex and nuanced topic. There are a number of different reasons why it is prohibited, and there are also a number of alternative ways to dispose of toilet paper on Shabbat. It is important to understand the law and to find ways to comply with it in a way that is both respectful and practical.

The History of the Prohibition on Tearing Toilet Paper on Shabbat

The prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat is a relatively recent one. It is not mentioned in any of the early rabbinic texts, and it is only in the 19th century that we begin to see a few references to it.

One of the earliest references to the prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat is found in a responsum by Rabbi Moshe Sofer (1762-1839). In this responsum, Rabbi Sofer discusses the question of whether it is permissible to tear toilet paper on Shabbat. He concludes that it is not permissible, because tearing toilet paper is considered to be a form of muktzeh, or forbidden work.

Rabbi Sofer’s responsum was followed by a number of other rabbinic rulings on the same issue. In general, these rulings agreed with Rabbi Sofer’s that it is not permissible to tear toilet paper on Shabbat. However, there were a few dissenting opinions.

One of the most notable dissenting opinions was that of Rabbi Yisrael Meir Kagan (1838-1933), known as the Chofetz Chaim. In his book Mishnah Berurah, Rabbi Kagan argues that it is permissible to tear toilet paper on Shabbat, as long as it is done in a way that does not involve any unnecessary waste.

The debate over the prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat continued into the 20th century. In 1950, the Israeli Chief Rabbinate issued a ruling that it is permissible to tear toilet paper on Shabbat, as long as it is done in a way that does not involve any unnecessary waste. This ruling was reaffirmed in 1981 by the Israeli Supreme Rabbinical Council.

Today, the prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat is still a matter of debate among Orthodox Jews. However, the majority of Orthodox rabbis agree with the ruling of the Israeli Chief Rabbinate and the Israeli Supreme Rabbinical Council, and they permit the tearing of toilet paper on Shabbat.

When did the prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat begin?

The prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat is a relatively recent one. It is not mentioned in any of the early rabbinic texts, and it is only in the 19th century that we begin to see a few references to it.

One of the earliest references to the prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat is found in a responsum by Rabbi Moshe Sofer (1762-1839). In this responsum, Rabbi Sofer discusses the question of whether it is permissible to tear toilet paper on Shabbat. He concludes that it is not permissible, because tearing toilet paper is considered to be a form of muktzeh, or forbidden work.

Rabbi Sofer’s responsum was followed by a number of other rabbinic rulings on the same issue. In general, these rulings agreed with Rabbi Sofer’s that it is not permissible to tear toilet paper on Shabbat. However, there were a few dissenting opinions.

One of the most notable dissenting opinions was that of Rabbi Yisrael Meir Kagan (1838-1933), known as the Chofetz Chaim. In his book Mishnah Berurah, Rabbi Kagan argues that it is permissible to tear toilet paper on Shabbat, as long as it is done in a way that does not involve any unnecessary waste.

The debate over the prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat continued into the 20th century. In 1950, the Israeli Chief Rabbinate issued a ruling that it is permissible to tear toilet paper on Shabbat, as long as it is done in a way that does not involve any unnecessary waste. This ruling was reaffirmed in 1981 by the Israeli Supreme Rabbinical Council.

Today, the prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat is still a matter of debate among Orthodox Jews. However, the majority of Orthodox rabbis agree with the ruling of the Israeli Chief Rabbinate and the Israeli Supreme Rabbinical Council, and they permit the tearing of toilet paper on Shabbat.

How has the prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat evolved over time?

The prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat has evolved over time. In the early days of the prohibition, it was interpreted very strictly. This meant that it was not permissible to tear toilet paper in any way, even if it was done in a way that did not involve any unnecessary waste.

However, over time, the prohibition on tearing toilet paper on Shabbat has become more relaxed. Today, it is generally accepted that it is permissible to tear toilet paper in a way that does not involve any unnecessary waste. This means that it is permissible to tear toilet

Q: Why can’t you tear toilet paper on Shabbat?

A: Tearing is considered a form of work, and work is prohibited on Shabbat. Toilet paper is considered a form of muktzeh, which means that it is not permitted to be moved on Shabbat. Therefore, it is not possible to tear toilet paper on Shabbat.

Q: What can I use instead of toilet paper on Shabbat?

A: There are a few different options that you can use instead of toilet paper on Shabbat. You can use a bidet, which is a device that sprays water to clean the body. You can also use a wet wipe, which is a pre-moistened towelette that can be used to clean the body. Finally, you can also use a piece of cloth that has been dampened with water.

Q: What if I really need to use toilet paper on Shabbat?

A: If you absolutely need to use toilet paper on Shabbat, there are a few things that you can do. You can tear the toilet paper before Shabbat, and then store it in a sealed container. You can also ask someone else to tear the toilet paper for you. Finally, you can use a pre-torn roll of toilet paper, which is available at some Jewish stores.

Q: Is it ever permissible to tear toilet paper on Shabbat?

A: There are a few rare cases where it is permissible to tear toilet paper on Shabbat. For example, if you are in a life-threatening situation, you may tear toilet paper in order to clean yourself. Additionally, if you are unable to use a bidet or a wet wipe, you may tear toilet paper in order to clean yourself. However, it is important to note that these are only exceptions to the rule, and that tearing toilet paper on Shabbat is generally prohibited.

there are a number of reasons why tearing toilet paper on Shabbat is considered to be forbidden. First, it is considered to be a form of work, which is prohibited on Shabbat. Second, it is considered to be a waste of resources, as toilet paper is not a necessary item on Shabbat. Third, it can be seen as a form of disrespect for the Sabbath, as it is a day of rest and relaxation. By following these guidelines, you can help to ensure that you are observing Shabbat in the proper way.

Author Profile

Liana Farrell
Liana Farrell
Liana Farrell is the owner of toiletty.com. She is a mom of two and is very passionate about home improvement.

Liana has ten years of home improvement experience, and in her own words, she said: “I love improving the home, and I’m very passionate about keeping the home in the best possible condition. I love it!”

Liana Farrell balances beauty and functionality when she goes about her home improvement jobs.