Should You Replace Your Bathtub with a Shower Only?

AvatarByLiana Farrell Bathtub Queries

Should I Replace My Bathtub With a Shower Only?

Your bathtub is one of the most used fixtures in your home. But is it still the best use of your space? If you’re not using your bathtub very often, you may be wondering if it’s time to replace it with a shower only.

There are a number of factors to consider when making this decision, including your personal needs, the size of your bathroom, and your budget. In this article, we’ll take a closer look at the pros and cons of replacing your bathtub with a shower only, so you can make an informed decision about what’s best for your home.

The Pros of Replacing Your Bathtub with a Shower Only

There are a number of benefits to replacing your bathtub with a shower only, including:

  • More space: A shower only takes up less space than a bathtub, so you can free up valuable square footage in your bathroom. This is especially beneficial if you have a small bathroom.
  • Less maintenance: Bathtubs require more maintenance than showers, as they need to be cleaned more often and the water needs to be drained after each use. This can be a hassle, especially if you don’t have a lot of time to keep up with the cleaning.
  • More safety: Showers are generally safer than bathtubs, especially for children and the elderly. This is because there is no water to slip in, and the shower head is at a lower height, making it easier to reach.
  • Better for your health: Showers are better for your health than bathtubs, as they help to improve circulation and lower blood pressure. This is because the warm water helps to dilate your blood vessels and the jets of water can help to massage your muscles.

The Cons of Replacing Your Bathtub with a Shower Only

There are also a few cons to consider when replacing your bathtub with a shower only, including:

  • Less versatility: Showers are less versatile than bathtubs, as they can’t be used for bathing children or pets. They also can’t be used for relaxing soaks or hydrotherapy.
  • Less comfortable: Showers can be less comfortable than bathtubs, especially if you have back pain or other mobility issues. This is because you have to stand up for the entire shower, which can be tiring.
  • More expensive: Showers can be more expensive than bathtubs, as they require more plumbing and fixtures. They can also be more difficult to install, which can add to the cost.

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to replace your bathtub with a shower only is a personal one. You’ll need to weigh the pros and cons carefully to decide what’s best for your needs.

Pros Cons Overall
  • More space
  • Easier to clean
  • More affordable
  • Less comfortable
  • Not as versatile
  • May not be suitable for everyone
  • Depends on your needs and preferences

A bathtub is a fixture that can be found in many homes. It provides a place to relax and soak after a long day. However, bathtubs can also take up a lot of space and be difficult to clean. If you are considering replacing your bathtub with a shower only, there are a few things you should consider.

Pros and Cons of Replacing a Bathtub with a Shower Only

There are both pros and cons to replacing a bathtub with a shower only. Some of the benefits of replacing a bathtub with a shower only include:

  • More space: A shower only takes up less space than a bathtub. This can be a major advantage in small bathrooms.
  • Lower cost: Showers are typically less expensive than bathtubs. This can be a significant savings, especially if you are on a tight budget.
  • Easier to clean: Showers are easier to clean than bathtubs. This is because there is less surface area to clean and no need to worry about scrubbing out soap scum and mildew from the bathtub.

However, there are also some disadvantages to replacing a bathtub with a shower only. Some of the drawbacks of replacing a bathtub with a shower only include:

  • Less versatility: Showers are less versatile than bathtubs. This is because you cannot use a shower to bathe children or to soak in.
  • Less comfortable for bathing: Showers can be less comfortable for bathing than bathtubs. This is because you are standing up in the shower, which can be tiring for some people.
  • May not be suitable for people with disabilities: Showers may not be suitable for people with disabilities. This is because they can be difficult to get in and out of.

Factors to Consider When Deciding Whether to Replace a Bathtub with a Shower Only

There are a few factors you should consider when deciding whether to replace a bathtub with a shower only. These factors include:

  • The size of your bathroom: If you have a small bathroom, replacing your bathtub with a shower only can be a good option. This will free up space and make your bathroom feel more spacious.
  • Your budget: Showers are typically less expensive than bathtubs. However, you may need to pay more for a shower that has the features you want, such as a built-in seat or a rain shower head.
  • Your needs and preferences: If you do not use your bathtub very often, replacing it with a shower only may be a good option. This can save you time and money on your water bill. However, if you enjoy taking long baths, you may not want to replace your bathtub with a shower only.
  • The age and condition of your bathtub: If your bathtub is old and in disrepair, replacing it with a shower only may be a good option. This can save you money on repairs and maintenance. However, if your bathtub is in good condition, you may not need to replace it.

Whether or not you should replace your bathtub with a shower only is a personal decision. There are both pros and cons to consider. You should weigh the factors carefully to make the best decision for your needs.

Additional Resources

  • [The Pros and Cons of Replacing a Bathtub with a Shower](https://www.thespruce.com/pros-and-cons-of-replacing-a-bathtub-with-a-shower-4171437)
  • [How to Choose the Right Shower for Your Bathroom](https://www.homedepot.com/c/how-to-choose-the-right-shower-for-your-bathroom-hd08233278)
  • [How to Remove a Bathtub](https://www.familyhandyman.com/project/how-to-remove-a-bathtub/)
  • [How to Install a Shower](https://www.thisoldhouse.com/bathroom/how-to-install-a-shower)

3. How to Replace a Bathtub with a Shower Only

Replacing a bathtub with a shower only is a major project, but it can be a great way to update your bathroom and create more space. Here are the steps involved in the process:

Step 1: Remove the old bathtub

The first step is to remove the old bathtub. This can be a difficult and messy job, so it’s important to take your time and be careful.

To remove the bathtub, you will need the following tools:

  • A hammer
  • A pry bar
  • A saw
  • A bucket
  • A hose
  • A shop vac

1. Turn off the water to the bathtub.
2. Drain the water from the bathtub.
3. Remove the bathtub drain.
4. Remove the bathtub faucet.
5. Remove the bathtub bolts.
6. Pry the bathtub away from the wall.
7. Cut the bathtub away from the wall.
8. Remove the bathtub from the bathroom.
9. Clean up the mess.

Step 2: Install the new shower pan

The next step is to install the new shower pan. A shower pan is the waterproof base of the shower. It is made of a material such as fiberglass, acrylic, or porcelain.

To install the shower pan, you will need the following tools:

  • A tape measure
  • A level
  • A pencil
  • A saw
  • A hammer
  • A drill
  • A screwdriver
  • A caulking gun
  • A shower pan liner
  • A shower drain
  • A shower faucet
  • A shower head
  • A shower curtain

1. Measure the area where the shower pan will be installed.
2. Cut the shower pan to size.
3. Place the shower pan in the shower area.
4. Level the shower pan.
5. Secure the shower pan to the floor with screws.
6. Install the shower pan liner.
7. Install the shower drain.
8. Install the shower faucet.
9. Install the shower head.
10. Install the shower curtain.

Step 3: Install the shower walls and doors

The next step is to install the shower walls and doors. Shower walls are the vertical surfaces of the shower. They are typically made of fiberglass, acrylic, or porcelain. Shower doors are the horizontal surfaces of the shower. They are typically made of glass or acrylic.

To install the shower walls and doors, you will need the following tools:

  • A tape measure
  • A level
  • A pencil
  • A saw
  • A hammer
  • A drill
  • A screwdriver
  • A caulking gun
  • Shower walls
  • Shower doors
  • Shower hardware

1. Measure the area where the shower walls and doors will be installed.
2. Cut the shower walls and doors to size.
3. Place the shower walls and doors in the shower area.
4. Level the shower walls and doors.
5. Secure the shower walls and doors to the floor and ceiling with screws.
6. Install the shower hardware.

Step 4: Install the shower faucet and fixtures

The next step is to install the shower faucet and fixtures. Shower faucets are the valves that control the flow of water to the shower head. Shower fixtures are the accessories that are used to control the temperature and flow of water to the shower head.

To install the shower faucet and fixtures, you will need the following tools:

  • A tape measure
  • A level
  • A pencil
  • A saw
  • A hammer
  • A drill
  • A screwdriver
  • A caulking gun
  • Shower faucet
  • Shower fixtures
  • Shower hose
  • Shower head

1. Measure the area where the shower faucet and fixtures will be installed.
2. Cut the shower faucet and fixtures to size.
3. Place the shower faucet and fixtures in the shower area.
4. Level the shower faucet and fixtures.
5. Secure the shower faucet and fixtures to the wall with screws.
6. Connect the shower hose to the shower faucet.
7. Connect the shower head to the shower hose.

Step 5: Caulk the shower

The final step is to caulk the shower. Caulking is a sealant that is used to seal the joints between the shower walls, doors, and floor.

To caulk the shower, you will need the following tools:

  • A caulking gun
  • A caulking tube
  • A damp cloth

1. Apply a bead of caulk to the joints between the shower walls, doors,

Should I Replace My Bathtub With Shower Only?

Q: What are the benefits of replacing my bathtub with a shower only?

A: There are many benefits to replacing your bathtub with a shower only, including:

  • More space: A shower only takes up less space than a bathtub, so you can create a larger and more functional bathroom.
  • Easier to clean: A shower only is easier to clean than a bathtub, as there is no need to worry about scrubbing out the tub.
  • More accessible: A shower only is more accessible for people with disabilities or mobility issues.
  • More energy-efficient: A shower only uses less water than a bathtub, which can save you money on your water bill.

Q: What are the drawbacks of replacing my bathtub with a shower only?

A: There are a few drawbacks to replacing your bathtub with a shower only, including:

  • Less versatility: A shower only is less versatile than a bathtub, as you cannot take a bath in it.
  • Less comfortable: A shower only can be less comfortable than a bathtub, as you are standing up for the entire shower.
  • More expensive: A shower only can be more expensive than a bathtub, as you need to purchase a new shower stall and shower fixtures.

Q: How much does it cost to replace a bathtub with a shower only?

The cost of replacing a bathtub with a shower only will vary depending on the size and type of shower you choose, as well as the cost of labor. The average cost to replace a bathtub with a shower only is between \$3,000 and \$5,000.

Q: How long does it take to replace a bathtub with a shower only?

The length of time it takes to replace a bathtub with a shower only will vary depending on the size and type of shower you choose, as well as the experience of the contractor. The average time to replace a bathtub with a shower only is between 1 and 3 days.

Q: What is the best type of shower for my bathroom?

The best type of shower for your bathroom will depend on your personal needs and preferences. There are many different types of showers available, including:

  • Stand-up showers: Stand-up showers are the most common type of shower. They are typically installed in a corner of the bathroom and have a showerhead that is mounted on the wall.
  • Over-the-tub showers: Over-the-tub showers are installed over a bathtub. They typically have a showerhead that is mounted on the ceiling and a handheld showerhead that can be used for rinsing.
  • Walk-in showers: Walk-in showers are fully enclosed showers that are typically installed in large bathrooms. They have a showerhead that is mounted on the ceiling and a bench or seat for sitting.

Q: How do I choose the right shower for my bathroom?

When choosing a shower for your bathroom, you should consider the following factors:

  • The size of your bathroom: The size of your bathroom will determine the size of the shower you can install.
  • Your personal needs and preferences: You should choose a shower that meets your personal needs and preferences.
  • Your budget: You should choose a shower that fits your budget.

Q: How do I install a shower only?

Installing a shower only is a major project that should only be undertaken by experienced DIYers or professionals. If you are not comfortable with DIY projects, it is best to hire a professional to install your shower.

The steps involved in installing a shower only vary depending on the type of shower you choose. However, the general steps involved include:

1. Remove the old bathtub.
2. Install the new shower stall.
3. Install the shower fixtures.
4. Install the shower drain.
5. Install the shower head.
6. Install the shower curtain rod.

Q: What are the maintenance tips for a shower only?

To keep your shower only in good condition, you should follow these maintenance tips:

  • Clean the shower regularly. You should clean the shower regularly to prevent the build-up of soap scum and mold.
  • Use a shower liner. A shower liner will help to protect the shower from water damage.
  • Replace the shower head regularly. The shower head should be replaced every 5-10 years.
  • Inspect the shower for leaks regularly. Leaks should be repaired immediately to prevent water damage.

Q: What are the safety considerations for a shower only?

There are a few safety considerations

In this article, we’ve discussed the pros and cons of replacing your bathtub with a shower only. We’ve looked at the different factors to consider, such as the size of your bathroom, your budget, and your personal needs. Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to replace your bathtub with a shower only is a personal one. However, we hope that this article has provided you with the information you need to make an informed decision.

Here are the key takeaways from this article:

  • Shower only units are more affordable and take up less space than bathtubs.
  • They’re also easier to clean and maintain.
  • However, they may not be as comfortable or versatile as bathtubs.
  • If you’re considering replacing your bathtub with a shower only, be sure to weigh the pros and cons carefully before making a decision.

Author Profile

Liana Farrell
Liana Farrell
Liana Farrell is the owner of toiletty.com. She is a mom of two and is very passionate about home improvement.

Liana has ten years of home improvement experience, and in her own words, she said: “I love improving the home, and I’m very passionate about keeping the home in the best possible condition. I love it!”

Liana Farrell balances beauty and functionality when she goes about her home improvement jobs.